Reimagining ESG Metrics: Developing a Human-Centered Corporate Accountability and Sustainability Index
Environmental, social, and governance (ESG) factors are increasingly important in today’s global economy. High-profile business failures highlight the need for more forward-looking governance metrics. More recent events, such as the pandemic and the climate crisis, have shifted the focus to social metrics and adaptatio...
1. Introduction
Environmental, social, and governance (ESG) factors are increasingly important in today’s global economy. High-profile business failures highlight the need for more forward-looking governance metrics. More recent events, such as the pandemic and the climate crisis, have shifted the focus to social metrics and adaptation - related governance investments. Research and practice in ESG metrics must be fundamentally rethought to address these issues. The demand for internet -based reporting frameworks is increasing because conducting a decent corporate and governmental ESG analysis by hand takes significant time. However, the budding ESG tech sector is still in a still-formative, chaotic, gold -rush state, and incentives can spur green hacking. Thus, crowdsourcing human expertise and rationalising global ESG research are recommended. New open...
2. Understanding ESG Metrics
Environmental, social, and governance (ESG) metrics are a broad set of non - financial performance indicators that collectively communicate an investment, company, or fund's sustainability rating . These metrics generally fall into three categories: environmental performance indicators, social performance indicators, and governance performance indicators. Organisations of all types, including large corporations, small businesses, and non -profits, may be rated on these ESG metrics or choose to disclose metrics voluntarily. Utilising non-financial performance metrics to gauge organisational performance is not new. New models to assess corporate performance based on social and environmental performance began emerging as far back as the 1970s. ESG metrics evolved from prior frameworks or attempts to measure the impact of corporate social res...
3. Challenges with Current ESG Metrics
As impact investing continues gaining traction, so does the need for accurate, reliable tools for effective decision-making. Environmental, social, and governance (ESG) metrics emerged to tackle this issue. Yet, they have come under increasing scrutiny lately. This section details the limitations, criticisms, and challenges with current ESG metrics and their implications for a reimagined approach. The limitations and criticisms of ESG metrics can be grouped into four broad categories: • Data issues: Current metrics are severely limited in assessing actual impact based on data sets used, lack robust methodologies, and are based on incomplete or less forward-looking data. • Irrelevance: As alternatives are made available, current metrics risk becoming irrelevant. • Encouragement of superficial change: Current metrics can encourage minimal o...
4. The Case for Human-Centered ESG Metrics
ESG and corporate sustainability must be restructured based on economics that is aligned with humanity’s goals for equity, dignity, well-being, and opportunity for all. Forgoing a quick fix to reimagine ESG metrics risks the further entrenchment of a non-humancentric economy. Even if enhanced standardised ESG metrics are implemented at scale, their design will be instrumental in mitigating or exacerbating systemic inequities in political, economic, environmental, and social institutions and systems. Crowd and expert sources hack ideation of human- centred metrics for better corporate accountability and pathways toward systemic reimagining ESG as human -centred, people and planet -aligned, voluntary, and publicly accessible commons for all. Reimagining existing ESG metrics toward a dialogue with a global diversity of people’s conceptions o...
Kingsly, K. M. (2026). Reimagining ESG Metrics: Developing a Human-Centered Corporate Accountability and Sustainability Index. Kelly Mua Kingsly Policy Monograph Series. Ref.: KMK-PB-2026-27.